Aug 23, 2017, 4:53 AM

Shockingly a new poster is arguing about this as if we haven't read literally everything they just typed dozens of times before!

Regardless of what is good or sensible, what is reasonable, it doesn't fucking work. Option 1: You can trust people to just use dice and negotiate. The result is well explored: it's your average WoD game, where people regularly argue and fight over these things, get angry at people for daring to roll social interactions, lie or refuse to honor them, use them to try and enforce TS, etc. Option 2: You create code to enforce the dice! Your result is Firan, where people abused the social imperative commands with little RP, the code had no ability to deal with any relevant situational modifiers, and staff was frequently called in to arbitrate/invalidate the results anyway because they were frequently abused and/or people didn't like the outcomes. Oh, and people still used it to try and force TS.

It will never work.

It will never work.

It will never work.