Mar 3, 2018, 5:32 AM

I don't think I would be a terrible Gm just one with a different view than you prefer. there are many style, for example where do you stand on GMs fudging dice? I personally would leave a game where the Gm did that, other people see no issue with it.
The Gm who fudges is not terrible just not to my taste, much like my not fudging resulting in PCs losing and in some cases dying has cause others to leave my games
To be the skill thing is along the same lines, the rules provide a story framework they are not a set of fictional physics. And I would be consistent, I would not let Bill try to perform surgery with medicine one nor Bob nor anyone.