@bobotron said in World of Darkness -- Alternative Settings:
@распутин
Because Foreign City by Night inevitably becomes 'All Ameican Expats in Foreign City by Night'? People write what they know.
I definitely see your point. We used to re-imagine Russian heroes as communists even though communism as an idea had not existed at the time these men were alive, nor did they in reality conform to communist ideals at all. To portray one of these men as both non-communist, and as a worthy historical figure to be honored, would invite serious consequences upon oneself. It was unthinkable that someone could contradict communism yet still be a valuable person.
I see Westerners repeating this mistake. All past heroes must be looked at through the lens of current ethical precepts, and if they err too strongly from them, you must stop honoring them, and destroy their monuments and their memory. Men who helped found your civilization must be denounced entirely because in addition to that they were racists, which is unacceptable now. It's a twisted and psychotic view of history.
Considering this carefully, I think that maybe enforcing setting involvement is the necessary limitation these users must accept: no, your character can't be above the human trafficking ring, because in order to get Vitae, they have to be actively involved in it. The people operating this ring are smarter than your character so whatever he attempts to do to bypass it will not work, and worse, might get him sent to some kind of gulag-like forced labor camp, where he will burn alive in the sun within a day, and be forgotten in less than a week. In order to survive, your character must be a bad person, and you as a player shouldn't be free to evade that.