MU Soapbox

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Muxify
    • Mustard

    Historical MUSHes

    Mildly Constructive
    24
    85
    4805
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • P
      paperbrilliant last edited by

      Are there any around? It seems like whenever I look I find ones that have died a slow death.

      tek 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
      • tek
        tek @paperbrilliant last edited by

        @paperbrilliant I would be interested in one of these!

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • Y
          yyrqun last edited by

          I'd love to join a game like this! Good old slice of life drama in anything from Rome to the medieval period, to Regency England, to the Wild West would be an awesome setting.

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
          • S
            Seraphim73 last edited by

            Depending on the era, I would totally be down for this. The problems that I've seen with them in the past tends to be "depending on the era," and also "how historical do you want it." Because if it's too historical, than the average player can't play it, and if it's too Hollywood, then the people who really like the era will get frustrated by everyone else. There has to be happy medium, I'm sure someone will find it, I just don't know that I've seen it yet.

            tek Saulot 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 4
            • tek
              tek @Seraphim73 last edited by

              @Seraphim73 said in Historical MUSHes:

              Depending on the era, I would totally be down for this. The problems that I've seen with them in the past tends to be "depending on the era," and also "how historical do you want it." Because if it's too historical, than the average player can't play it, and if it's too Hollywood, then the people who really like the era will get frustrated by everyone else. There has to be happy medium, I'm sure someone will find it, I just don't know that I've seen it yet.

              You ran a great game with The 8th Sea. I'd love to see something like that again.

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • RnMissionRun
                RnMissionRun last edited by

                If historical accuracy doesn't matter too much, there's at least one and possibly two 7th Sea games in the works. The one I know of for certain is being made by a friend I used to play with on Holotrek and WNO. I've been helping her with the code and it's really starting to shape up (it's Evennia, btw). The other one could be just a rumor. One of the people that logs on to my friend's game has occasionally remarked that she's working on her own game. No one has seen any proof of this yet, so far as I know.

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                • Saulot
                  Saulot @Seraphim73 last edited by

                  @Seraphim73 I know I sound like a pessimist, but I don't think there is a happy medium. You gotta accept that you can't please both audiences, and will have to cater to one. I may be wrong since I haven't been mushing for long, and there may have been games that have accomplished it.

                  Y'all finished or y'all done? I ain't go no more talkin'.

                  faraday S 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 3
                  • Goldfish
                    Goldfish last edited by

                    Horror MUX has had one present day story. The first. Then it was 2149 on a space station. Then 1902 in the dying Old West. Then 1989 through the 80s horror film lens. Soon: 1934, Dust Bowl.

                    I think the cyclical nature of the game lends itself well to period settings, I feel. We aren't there long enough to fret too much about accuracy or long term issues. I love, love, love historical settings so I'm terribly happy.

                    Am I the baddie?
                    Yes. Always yes.

                    egg 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                    • Pandora
                      Pandora last edited by

                      Historical accuracy isn't going to happen in the current era of gaming, where certain themes aren't allowed due to being A) unpleasant and B) a pain in the ass to moderate.

                      There's also the fact that most people are not experts in one bygone era, let alone enough of them that they'd be able to just jump in and immerse themselves.

                      There's also the fact that the average game-runner would run themselves ragged trying to correct unthematic behaviors, and likely wind up being accused of 'wrongfunning' their players. Alternatively, they can let things slide if they aren't 'too problematic' and that's how theme-slip begins and you wake up one day and your Period Drama has turned into a modern-day cosplay tea party.

                      Also for most of history, people were really dirty, didn't wear particularly nice clothes unless they were rich or a whore, lice were more common than having all your teeth, and women were treated kind of like shit. So have fun making that game.

                      Tinuviel about 9 hours ago
                      I hate you with the power of a thousand Pandoras.

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 6
                      • faraday
                        faraday @Saulot last edited by

                        @Saulot said in Historical MUSHes:

                        @Seraphim73 I know I sound like a pessimist, but I don't think there is a happy medium. You gotta accept that you can't please both audiences, and will have to cater to one. I may be wrong since I haven't been mushing for long, and there may have been games that have accomplished it.

                        I think it depends on what you mean by "happy medium". There have been numerous historical games that have done "Hollywood History". Like @Pandora says, this means that the historical setting is much cleaner, fancier, healthier, more progressive and more adventurous than its historical counterpart. Sure, there are people who grit their teeth at the historical inaccuracies, but I don't think it's any worse than Deadwood or Pick-a-Crown-Drama on TV.

                        Tinuviel 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                        • Tinuviel
                          Tinuviel @faraday last edited by

                          @faraday said in Historical MUSHes:

                          Sure, there are people who grit their teeth at the historical inaccuracies

                          Most of us folks that have more than a passing interest in history mostly grit our teeth when people insist on being "historically accurate" but aren't. Fictional takes on history are fine and are done often enough. We just get people trying time and again to be "historically accurate" rather than just using history as a story tool.

                          He/Him

                          faraday Ganymede 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 2
                          • faraday
                            faraday @Tinuviel last edited by

                            @Tinuviel said in Historical MUSHes:

                            Most of us folks that have more than a passing interest in history mostly grit our teeth when people insist on being "historically accurate" but aren't. Fictional takes on history are fine and are done often enough. We just get people trying time and again to be "historically accurate" rather than just using history as a story tool.

                            The problem with that is that "Historically Accurate" is a scale, not a yes/no checkbox. I don't think anybody would want to play a western that was 100% historically accurate because it would be bleak and boring. Your PC would be be more likely to die of dysentery than to have an interesting adventure or drama.

                            Hollywood westerns, for example, range in accuracy from Tarantino westerns (crazily over-the-top but entertaining) to Into the West (reasonably realistic but still over-dramatized). Your MUSH can draw the line anywhere along that scale. Where we have difficulty is defining that scale so people can come into the game with a common set of expectations.

                            Tinuviel 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                            • Tinuviel
                              Tinuviel @faraday last edited by

                              @faraday said in Historical MUSHes:

                              The problem with that is that "Historically Accurate" is a scale, not a yes/no checkbox.

                              Well, one can have various levels of accuracy but if it's not accurate it's not accurate. So saying that something is "historically accurate" is the wrong term to use. "Inspired by a historical setting" or "set in the backdrop of the XYZ," would be better. Nobody gets to be the historical pendant, then.

                              He/Him

                              faraday peasoupling 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 2
                              • faraday
                                faraday @Tinuviel last edited by

                                @Tinuviel said in Historical MUSHes:

                                Well, one can have various levels of accuracy but if it's not accurate it's not accurate. So saying that something is "historically accurate" is the wrong term to use. "Inspired by a historical setting" or "set in the backdrop of the XYZ," would be better. Nobody gets to be the historical pendant, then.

                                I think that's being a little nitpicky about the terminology. Short of a documentary/non-fiction, nothing in fiction is 100% accurate, yet "accuracy" is the term people use in common parlance to describe Into the West as being "more accurate" than Hateful Eight.

                                That said, I've played on a number of historical games and I've never seen one say "We expect people to be historically accurate." Usually the gripes about accuracy come from individual players complaining that something is outside their personal bounds of what is "accurate enough" for their suspension of disbelief.

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                • surreality
                                  surreality last edited by surreality

                                  It would not surprise me to discover a few historically-themed games out there.

                                  I kinda doubt they'll ever be actively advertised here, though, as a very vocal portion of the forum population is extra vocal when it comes to telling folks who want to run a historical game that unless they bring all of the social and cultural issues up to better than the actual modern day standard re: equality, they are only not choosing to do that due to RL sexism, racism, etc. on the creator's part, and the creators clearly just want to call women whores and spit on LGBTQ and PoC.

                                  While this is complete nonsense on its face, this argument has come up often enough and played out the same way every damned time. It's not even a conversation worth having any more on account of this behavior. As a result, I would be sincerely stunned if anyone ever posted an ad for a historical game here. Hell, considering what's ascribed to people who want to create or run one, it's hard to imagine a creator not actively wincing if their game gets brought up on the forum, since they're going to get dragged through the mud on a very personal RL level in a spectacularly ugly way.

                                  Oh fucking well.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 7
                                  • peasoupling
                                    peasoupling @Tinuviel last edited by peasoupling

                                    You could have a game entirely staffed and played by people who did their PhDs on that particular time and place and it still wouldn't be historically accurate to anyone's satisfaction. Especially their own. Which they'd let each other know, vigorously!

                                    Beyond that, you do have people who go "well, this was pretty uncommon, so it's historically inaccurate" and people who go "well, this happened once, so it's historically accurate" and people who go "we have no evidence this was impossible, so it's historically accurate". And, of course, "well, this sticks it to the libs, so it's historically accurate".

                                    But even if everything is historically inaccurate, some things are more historically inaccurate than others, and in different directions. So staff would still need to decide what exactly they're going with, what their specific vision for the setting is and how rigidly they want to enforce it, regardless of whether they call themselves historically accurate or a medieaeval fantasie.

                                    mietze 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 7
                                    • mietze
                                      mietze @peasoupling last edited by

                                      @peasoupling I love historical setting games, but that is one of my least favorite parts about it, the competitive masturbation on channel about who is more educated about what esoteric historical accuracy that like hasn't even come up in the scope of the game, and how everyone else is an idiot for not knowing everything like the masturbator does.

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 4
                                      • Ganymede
                                        Ganymede Admin @Tinuviel last edited by

                                        @Tinuviel said in Historical MUSHes:

                                        Most of us folks that have more than a passing interest in history mostly grit our teeth when people insist on being "historically accurate" but aren't. Fictional takes on history are fine and are done often enough. We just get people trying time and again to be "historically accurate" rather than just using history as a story tool.

                                        I'd just like it if a period piece stuck somewhat near the technological level and actual world history. Like, please, no grenades at the Battle of Acre, I don't care what you think the History Channel said existed or aliens.

                                        “It is better to live doing the things that you like. It is foolish to live within this dream of a world seeing unpleasantness and doing only things that you do not like.” -- Yamamoto Tsunetomo.

                                        Saulot 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                        • Saulot
                                          Saulot @Ganymede last edited by

                                          @Ganymede the history channel said the Nazis were there, and that ancient aliens caused it.

                                          Y'all finished or y'all done? I ain't go no more talkin'.

                                          Ganymede 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                          • Ganymede
                                            Ganymede Admin @Saulot last edited by

                                            @Saulot said in Historical MUSHes:

                                            @Ganymede the history channel said the Nazis were there, and that ancient aliens caused it.

                                            history channel

                                            “It is better to live doing the things that you like. It is foolish to live within this dream of a world seeing unpleasantness and doing only things that you do not like.” -- Yamamoto Tsunetomo.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 3
                                            • 4
                                            • 5
                                            • 1 / 5
                                            • First post
                                              Last post