Jul 18, 2016, 1:08 PM

For me it's just a matter of theme. You know how in some TV shows throwing a punch can land you into serious trouble because Law - some episodes of The Good Wife involved the threat of long-time imprisonment and repercussions for relatively minor problems. Similarly in The Preacher he gets to be in a fight in public and snap someone's arm until the bone shows in front of everyone but there's never a question of whether charges will be pressed or that there might be consequences; it's just not that type of show.

Cops and criminals in a nWoD should just be treated thematically. No, you can't really try to play the big by-the-book cop who arrests everyone for smoking pot or being in a bar fight, that's dumb. It's not that kind of game, and staff should just tell him all the charges were dropped the same night if he tries. If the baddies eat a baby in front of the character then yes, I'd say 'consequences' are in order though, yes.

It's just a matter of consistent and common sense. There's no need to have rules like "no cop can ever go after a PC" - nor the opposite.