@carex said in Development Thread: Sacred Seed:
Economically and socially it's really, really, a bad idea to leave outcast nobles alive. If you prune someone you need to remove all ties from them. Have a ritual of forgetting that erases them from all records and burns their belongings.
They need to not only be treated as if they are dead but as if they had never existed in the first place. If you can get away with it just kill them.
If you leave even a hint of noble ties then they have kids those kids might form a rebellion later. You can't have kids popping up taking portions of wealth or land unexpectedly because you let some pruned seedling walk away with an untapped legacy. It's horrible for the stability of the nation.
If you want to incorporate people moving from being a commoner to a noble then have multiple tiers of nobility. A titled and untitled nobility perhaps.
One tier that can inherit land and one that can only be awarded land by a higher noble. Once someone is awarded land they get a title and their offspring can then inherit land.
You don't want just any old commoner who wins the genetic lottery gaining political power. You need a system of gate-keeping.
On the other hand, it sounds like the mage gifts are only kept alive through fairly rigorous breeding and 'fresh' Seeded are often more powerful than those in the noble families. While that's a political threat, it's also a heck of an opportunity to bolster your family's bloodlines. Which might also provide a rationale for not killing Weeded nobles - they're still from a magic rich bloodline, and if they go out and breed with commoners, it might still raise the chance of throwing a fluke down the line that the family can then claim and breed back into the line.
Although the point about needing to control those common-born Seeded is important. If it weren't a persistent MU* setting, I would suggest that being married into a noble family would be required for a common-born Seeded to be fully acknowledged. But with PCs, that's a recipe for trouble, so I'd simply suggest, instead, that common-born Seeded get enthusiastically courted, with an eye to getting them to sign a contract (or whatever the equivalent is) that dedicates their service to a noble house, and that many of these get married off to one of the noble lines, as well, in hopes that their children will inherent the power.