@auspice When the MU I was on shut down, I had nowhere else to really go. Wora was... well. WORA. This place didn't exist yet, and I wasn't really aware of any other MU that had the right feel or setting or sense of community. Eventually I found it in Arx, but there was a 2-3 year period where I didn't have anything.
After about a year of no RP, I accidentally ran into an RP group on FFXIV, and I was so excited I just wanted to RP again and get involved in something. It is nothing like what I was looking for at all. Everything you said is true. It's all power posing and just... I did it for a while because I was starved for it. It was a port in a storm.
That was basically the kind of RP I did before MU, which I'd only discovered about 8-9 years ago. Sure, I'd found MUDs before then, but I quickly lost interest when all the most popular muds were devoid of any kind of role playing, and were just all about mob grinding basically the antithesis of everything that I am.
@Moonman Mentioned that they're on internet forums doing play-by-post. That's how I got started. Back when I was 16, there was a random Star Wars RP that started up in a forum that doesn't exist anymore. I got hooked on the concept and when the board went defunct I looked for other places to RP, and found a Wheel of Time based community. I liked it but there was something missing. I hated the pacing and there was never a feeling of risk to it. Everything was safe. If a character died, it's because they decided to write their characters out. Well my friend introduced my to a MU she had been playing on the side. As it turns out, this was exactly what I had been looking for. Sure, to the rest of the MU community it was a cesspit that should be avoided at all costs, but I didn't know that!
The point of all that is simply that, if it weren't for these other avenues of RP I never would've been drawn to the hobby in the first place. There are other potential MUers out there, and they don't even realize it. They need to be introduced and brought in, and that's part of the problem. This hobby is virtually invisible unless you know it's there. Sure, different culture and all that, but the people that don't fit in tend to get weeded out pretty quickly, but there are others that would have been a part of that power posing culture that Auspice mentioned that would really prefer a more tightly knit experience with more structure and rules, and as far as I'm concerned, this is the format, bar none that gets the job done. Nothing else in my experience even comes close.
I mean, sure this is a small community, and I don't think it's going to last forever. This is as niche as niche gets. Is that a bad thing? The people we have here are dedicated to the hobby. We love it, and we pour so much of ourselves into it. Wouldn't you agree that it's better to have a game of a few dozen dedicated and passionate players, than hundreds of power posers just looking to act out a fetish or a hero fantasy? My favorite hobby is small, weird, and impossible to explain to anybody on the outside, and I like it that way. I'll be around for as long as there's a community to be a part of.