To summarize: The game idea I am working on is set in Manhattan, New York City—potentially in the "vague" 1970s or 1980s; haven't decided for sure yet. One moment I lean toward a That 70s Show desire for disco and Hell's Angels and the other I ponder the nostalgic approach of The Goldbergs' pop culture silliness.
Regardless, the game setting would be centered upon a fictional, magical "pocket realm" neighborhood populated by modern fantasy characters.
Question/Loose Opinion Poll: As a potential player of such a game, would you be satisfied if only the fictional neighborhood was fully fleshed out as grid rooms? If "Outer New York" were built as a small network of vague neighborhood/borough rooms surrounding contemporary landmarks or potentially centered on city parks. If +Temproom code were made available to allow people to make more specific locations for the duration of play within those areas.
Your thoughts as new or veteran gamers?
(Edit to fix a typo.)