@Sparks said in Difference between an NPC and a Staff PC?:
It's not even maliciously done, but OOC knowledge will make even tiny IC hints seem much more obvious than they really are
Because there are players who play against the GM, sometimes not even maliciously. If the GM has a mystery, the players, not the characters, are trying to figure it out. So many D&D modules are built around this conceit.
I’ve played games where the GM is (are) working so closely with the players that this drama goes away and everyone wants to find out what the characters do. I love this kind of storyteller. (On my list: @Ganymede , Troy, and yes, even Ernst’s player once.)
@Tinuviel said in Difference between an NPC and a Staff PC?:
And lord help you if your NPC says something that is incorrect because the character themselves doesn't know the truth...
We need a way to gently break it to people that NPCs are sometimes parts of the living world and not cartoon characters or plot dispensers.
The NPCs in Haunted Memories’ Changeling sphere may not have been nuanced, but when they stabbed you in the back you weren’t surprised.