@Arkandel said:
@Ganymede Here's a question for you (all).
Would an elimination format such as FIBA's and NCAA be worth it, as it adds to the excitement ('anything can happen in one game') but takes away from the measure of a better team?
Maybe add a third possibility for a point differential over two games (home court advantage=you play second) if you want.
Noooope. In a full-length series, the best team should come out on top. Once in a while you'll get a major upset (8th Warriors over 1st Mavericks in 6 about a decade ago now, but that was also a bad matchup for Dallas), but normally the best team will get through even with a hiccup or two. The advantage to taking care of business quickly can mean a few extra days of rest while next round's opponent is in a grind, though that also has the chance of breaking your own rhythm if you have too many days away from game action.
But, no. With the money on the line, the endorsements, the length of the season and all that, I don't think you'll ever see a one-and-done format or anything that has some sort of points-based advantage. It's going to get decided on the court.
I don't even really like the one-game wild card play-in thing with MLB, but they're determined to have more teams in the mix for the postseason and unless you start the season earlier or chop off a week or two of the regular season to avoid routinely going into November with the World Series, the one-game wild card, best-of-5 division series, best-of-7 championship series and World Series format isn't terrible.
What gets to be difficult is when one team has an ace or two they can line up to pitch twice each in a long series, while the opponent may have had to use their ace over the final weekend (or in the wild card game) just to get to the division series. But, that's the way it goes. Even then, sending Kershaw or Price or whoever else out there isn't a guarantee of an automatic win.
When you have a wild card situation, those teams do kind of have to be kept at some sort of disadvantage compared to the division winners, so their path is going to be tougher with less margin for error. In sports where you have no wild card and it's strictly seedings, that's different.