@Thenomain said in Changeling: The Lost Update [CofD]:
Having peeked at the Geist 2e rules, they are now very specifically not alive.
There's plenty in the 2e manuscript that says they're actually alive again. It even uses those specific words, "alive again". There's also a condition called "Dead" which happens to the Bound when they die again and their Geist goes on a rampage. The way they resolve it is to return from the dead once more.
There are many lines that say or imply they're no longer dead once they take the Bargain:
"You may not be dead, but you’ve died and now you live the difference."
"When the force keeping you alive wants something, you have no choice but to feel it."
"No one manner of death guarantees someone will choose to Bargain their way back to life."
"But Sin-Eaters share one conviction: If human will can turn back death, it can accomplish anything."