@Spawnblade said:
@Coin - You say you (Eldritch) don't want to be "the next big thing." Does this mean that you do not want a larger player base / new players? It seems you'd prefer a lot of niche servers, rather than one where a lot of people with differing views/personalities can clash. Is this correct?
No, not really. I mean, it's not wrong in that I don't want to have a huge, sprawling game, but it's not correct in that I don't want new players. So I guess it's a contradictory position to take when you ask it that way?
The crux of the issue is that I want to tell stories in my setting that I can include people in. With larger player bases, that becomes impossible, because I can't include enough people to ever feel like I'm being inclusive enough. Further, large games are unwieldly and hard to manage, require excessive amount of administrative staffers, which inevitably create extra drama. But most importantly: I prefer more accessible numbers, and I also think that it will benefit the entire hobby to have people spread out among other games rather than moving, lemming-style, from one big game to another.
I suppose my aversion to small / shrinking player bases is founded upon what often happens when we humans interact with the same people day after day with nothing to shake things up -- we start talking about the weather. Regardless, I appreciate your desire to see all of these places succeed. I wish more people held such goodwill.
If you find yourself with nothing to talk about the weather, and wanting to shake something up, do it. I'm not saying you, personally, are someone who relies on others to shake things up for you, but that's the impression your comment gives. Meanwhile, if I really want some action to take place on a game and I have interest from other people--real interest, not just whining about 'nothing is happening' while they don't even try to participate with some enthusiasm--I will run the hell out of a plot.
It's the same principle I apply to "gosh, this game sucks, it could be done so much better." Well, okay, butterfly, go on and do it better then. I mean, even if Eldritch bombs, at least no one will be able to say "Coin whined a lot, but never tried to do it himself".
Again, this isn't me being defensive; just my view on your opinion regarding needing new blood to shake things up. Plot shakes things up. Otherwise, all you're adding is another person who you will eventually get to know and who will eventually join you in the "nothing is happening" spiral.