@arkandel said in Great TV:
I think at this point what I expect (demand?) from book adaptations is very simple: Love the original work. Try to put that on the screen.
I disagree with this premise. If you want to relive the story from the books, then you should read the books. Every video adaptation of a story that doesn't have a LOTR budget has to make allowances and changes to fit the story into the narrative that you have.
Frankly, Wheel of Time would have been hella boring if they had stuck to the original source material. It was a whole bunch of scared dumb kids being scared and dumb, and their mentor figure being distant and unhelpful while they all contemplated the up-to-that-point largely theoretical prophecy and what they might be able to do with their fledgling powers until you get to the end of the thing, each of them lost in their own heads and generally just being judgmental and catty of everyone around them.
If you're going to have to tell a different story based on the medium, you might as well tell a fresh and interesting take on it. Also, there is absolutely nothing to say that this isn't just a different turning of the wheel, especially since
***Book spoilers ohnoes.***
click to show
rand didn't actually win at the end of the books and the future he created was a hellscape no matter which way it ended. Dark one won.
I know that I discussed that theory at length with @Devrex when I finished the books and was left a little 'what the actual f*ck' at the end of it. The show did way better for me.