I prefer the vague, and open to interpretation. Because people come in many shapes and sizes and what they do, also.
What you're saying is you prefer the author's interpretation.
I also don't want to play in an even field and expecting to do so, even on a MUSH is unrealistic. Time will increase the gulf.
Players that join in 5 years down the road will not be anywhere near the capabilities of , well you get it.... extreme example.
The whole idea of a MUSH is to create a shared world and a way to interact in it. My idea of a world is not exactly one where everyone
is equal.
Strong personalities? Will always push. Doesn't matter what system. Ditto with the rest .... charisma, power gaming or popularity, etc.
As for +1D being the same, etc. Doubt it. But it's a choice, not mandatory. People make decisions to take X, Y and or Z, for whatever reason. The whole concept of being worried about somebody else's interpretation is kind of weird to me.
Part of the beauty of Supers!, especially when it come to outcomes is that the player has more choices, and I like that. Only a power gamer or min maxer would be worried about that. The entire idea is that everyone have fun. Let me give... an example.
Charlie: I want to stop Megan from getting away. I zap her with my power bolt.....
Rolls. Yay. Dance. Result: 2D damage. That should take her out, she only has 2D Fortitude right?
Megan(GM): Yeah, but since you were trying to stop her from getting away, Megan is going to choose to split the damage between
Fortitude and Reaction. You hit her in the leg........but she's still hopping along....
I like that flexibility. I will grant you, however, that this tends not to work very well PvP, and to prevent it, Charlie could have been more specific, perhaps, or it wouldn't matter. Possibly a policy thingie. According to the book rules, player hit gets to choose if they can justify it. That could be annoying, PvP wise and lead to plenty of arguments? That's why there's a GM, and definitely needs to be one if there is PvP occurring
There are definitely things to consider when creating a MUSH that go above and beyond a normal TT session/campaign.
Anyways, way way off topic.
My vote, btw, in case you didn't guess was for Supers! .
To answer ..... what I really want, though is just an original theme superhero mush. No, not quite that. A non DC/Marvel universe. In that regard, I'm like Misaventure and I don't want to deal with interpretations of cannon.