Well it's definitely not for everyone.
The majority of WoD players always preferred stats and battle systems. It makes things easier. I myself host a D&D game every Sunday, so I know the pleasure of charts. On the good side: they bring out the gamer in everyone, help push forward creativity with a little pre-established help of things to choose from, but doing things from scratch? That's hard. Very few are drawn to having to work hard on character consistency, story building, and creativity with only freedom and inspiration as guidance. I'm lucky even one person showed interest (Thanks Sundown!).
On the other hand, going consentual with a family of friends or those who become thus in such a small place, there isn't any drama... Crazy right? There are many people out there who want to play dark games, but have preferences for this type of RP or that. We communicate these preferences. I know players out there who have undergone OOC psychological trauma and may not take to certain types of RP, but still want to play. These limits are respected and worked with :). I myself adore dark and gritty and thus, when my character is hurt/blackmailed/etc. by a friend's character, the spirit of good sportsmanship prevails with the little help of knowing that they are really on my side, and they are really here to tell a story.
Not to say this is better than WoD or anything like that. Just that it is a different MU* for a different taste! Sometimes we like charts, sometimes we want to go on a Haitus to London. It's a place to get away for existing characters should they want to as well. They are likewise welcome to take their experiences from here to any other WoD MU* or any MU* at all. We make no claim to ownership of anyone's characters I don't think anyone else does either.
And a little update: Today the builders decided to branch out and make a fictional district in London, thus, no one is pressed to recreate or be bound to, say, building Big Ben or Westminster Abbey. The District allows for more creativity, original places, and a smaller setting, rather than a huge spread-out grid of London!
And somehow through all this building and tearing down grids RP is still happening hah!