@Kestrel said in Personal Agency for Personal Boundaries:
There's a MUD called After Earth which has a "graphic" command which I think is a pretty neat idea:
Graphic is used to indicate that you are uncomfortable with the content of the RP, either due to its violent nature, sexual content, or some other reason which would justify omitting, editing, or otherwise toning the RP down to a more acceptable level.
When this command is used, all persons in the room should comply and reduce the level of detail. It should not require clarification or lapse into OOC discussion.
See also: MUDSEX, TURNS
Mudsex (TS) is also never supposed to occur without use of a "consent" command.
Helpfile for Consent
Syntax: consent list
consent give <name> [note]
consent revoke <name> [note]
consent alert <name> <reason>
consent check <name>
consent request <name> [reason]
All players are required to seek and obtain consent prior to engaging in sexually explicit roleplay.
The consent list command lists all characters that your character has provided consent to. Consent give <name> will add a character to the list, with an optional note if desired. Consent revoke <name> will remove consent at any time, also with an optional note.
All players are required to confirm that they have received consent before pursuing sexual intercourse using the consent check <name> command. Likewise, a player can OOCly declare their character's IC intentions with consent request <name> with an optional reason.
The consent system is PRIVATE. It does not report to staff unless a player uses the consent alert <name> <reason> command to tell staff that something is wrong.
At first glance I really like this idea, but a few concerns come to mind. First and foremost, at what point is one supposed to use the consent command? How far can RP go without the command being used? Kissing? Cuddling? Intimate non-penetrative touching? Let's say the RP has gotten that far, and although both characters seem into it, one of them has not provided consent or responded to the consent request command. Does that mean the scene should end? What if they didn't see it or don't know how the system works? Should you OOCly bring it up?
That brings us to another can of worms I see, which is people OOCly pressuring others to use the consent command. The helpfile doesn't seem to make any mention of whether or not it is against policy to OOCly pressure/cajole/convince anyone to give consent; as we all hopefully know, consent given under pressure isn't true consent.
Another issue is one that probably shouldn't be an issue, but if you've ever been in a game Discord with more than your immediate circle of friends, you've probably witnessed something of the sort: If Susie and Katie are RPing and flirting and having a good time and seem to mesh well and Katie activates consent before Susie and then Susie jokes to her Discord chat "Ha, I'm so awesome Katie gave me consent already and we're only having a drink in the bar." & then this triggers a wave of 'Katie is a slut' and 'Katie gave me consent her first day on the grid' and 'Katie is a mesbian all they want is TS' - you know, the usual slut-shaming, except now with coded 'proof' that player-of-Katie is DTF.
I don't mean to be a pessimist, I just know some of the people I unfortunately roleplay adjacent to; considering the downsides to everything is just a result to that.