@Arkandel said:
And I say that accepting the hypocrisy in that I'm quite fond of Ultimate Spider-man, and in that I really liked Tim Drake than any other incarnation of Robin.
Certain characters like Robin or the Flash were successfully made into legacy characters. Notably the person who took up the mantle of Robin next was acutely aware of the previous one and his history and most particularly in the case of Tim Drake, maintained a high regard for his predecessors. Similarly Barry Allen was Wally West's hero, and both of them looked up to Jay Garrick.
When you have a Ben Reilly it's basically just a cuckoo scenario where someone is replacing your Spider-Man with Folger's Crystals. That's cheap. Almost the same thing happened when Jean-Paul Valley became Batman for a minute. That was a blatantly temporary and empty replacement and even DC didn't look like they planned for that to last.