I will want to RP with a person if:
..their poses make me feel something.
Make me laugh. Make me cry. Make me nervous. Make me anxious about what is going to happen next. Make me stare at the screen and whisper 'holy shit' under my breath. Make me scramble to think how to react. Make me excited to RP with you again.
..their RP is generous.
I love it when I find someone whose RP gives me -- and others -- stuff to build off of. If I can leave a scene with a 'next step' in mind, it's been a good scene. And those kind of RPers inspire me to be better too! They prompt me to be reciprocal in that respect.
..they are super chill OOCly.
They are fun to talk to OOCly without being pushy or over-sharing. They express a desire to RP on the regular without giving me the impression that they feel entitled to it. I can go off and do my thing without them and they won't level a guilt-trip on me; but when we do get together and scene: MAGIC. If I have game questions, I can ask them without worrying about bias or IC-OOC crossover.
..they are not afraid to fail ICly.
I have found that the people who aren't fixated on being the MOST HEROIC HERO or the PRETTIEST PRINCESS are the people I have the most fun RPing with. They are less obsessed with winning and more concerned with telling an interesting story and, often, the best stories come out of failure and how one deals with adversity. Give me a fuck up over a hero any day of the week.
I will not want to RP with a person if:
..their poses give me nothing.
My general preference is for wordy poses with a lot of flavor thrown in but quick poses can be just as sharp, entertaining and impactful. What KILLS me is when I will do a pose where I've included several things for the other person to react to, ask some questions, pass the ball to them and get:
Jane doe smiles. "Yes."
Like. What am I supposed to do with that? Not RP with you ever again, that's what.
..they consistently page me the second I log on.
For fuck's sake. Give me a second. There is nothing more annoying than having someone page me immediately. Every. Single. Time. I. Log. On. Please, give me space. Even if I like you and we are friends, just let me breathe.
..they make our romance RP the totality of their character.
I like RPing romance. I do not like making it the entire point of my characters. It's just something in their lives, you know? If they have a romantic partner, they can still exist outside of that other person. We are not one person now. We do not need to be in every scene together. We do not need to run things by each other, have the same interests, need to be in all the same plots, know all the same people, etc.
..they make me their RL therapist.
I prefer to keep a distance between myself and most of the people I RP with. Yes, general pleasantries are fine! Knowing a little bit about our respective lives is cool! But RPing is my time to relax and have fun. I do not log on to hear about internet stranger's life drama and/or insecurities. I do not log on to listen to them dissect what someone said to them and figure out if it was benign or if they were being passive-aggressive and actually hate them. I do not log on to be a shoulder. Sure, there are folks that I have gotten close to and would absolutely help them work through shit but those are close relationships built up over time. This does not apply to the majority of people so please don't put your shit on me. I have enough of my own shit to deal with and this is my funtime to decompress from that shit, not deal with yours.
..they are insecure AF.
Please. If I do not answer your page right away, please don't bombard me with worry. 'Did I do something to upset you? Are you mad at me? Please let me know if I did something to irritate you! Are you OK?' I am probably in a scene and posing. I am probably at work and idle. But constantly having to validate that things are OK is going to quickly get us to a point where things are NOT OK.