@Pandora said in MSB: The meta-discussion:
A game is 'doing it right' when it doesn't wind up on WORA/MSB. That said, I think games that voluntarily advertise on MSB are very brave and open-minded, though they should keep in mind that they'll be attracting a specific sort of crowd that is heavily biased toward 'The Way We Do Things Just Because It's How We Do It'.
Are they?
This board is full of people who don't post very much, and even fuller of lurkers, and I suspect those are actually the audience for a lot of the advertising threads.
Which brings up something that does actually bug me. I have no issue with games that advertise here being bitched about. But I have this knee-jerk 'This is Bullshit' reaction to that bitching happening in their ad threads. Make a thread in the Hog Pit! Or a slightly veiled thread in the Constructive area. Link it in the ad thread (I don't actually think bitching about these games should be difficult to find), but it always rubs me the wrong way when these threads get taken over. Often times by bitches only tangentially related to the game that seem to boil down to slap-fights between players or about games from the Long Long Ago, or sprawling MU fights from the peeves thread that've spilled over.
Maybe I'm wrong about this, and maybe this is in the spirit of what MSB is designed for, but it Mehs me out whenever it happens.