@surreality Well if you're approving applications that have "I am a sniper, sniping is what I do because I am a sniper" then, yeah, you need to give them stuff to do or give them the agency to find that stuff on their own. The same goes for your other example. If you're approving characters that are heavily invested in arcane lore or occultism or whatever... then yes, you need to give them something to do.
Approving an application is more than just a rubber stamp saying 'yes you can play'. It's saying that the kind of character you're approving is one you want to see played. If you approve a character that you know won't get spotlight time, or much in the way of fulfilling RP without making such concerns absolutely clear to the player, you're just wasting their time.