@arkandel said in Book Recommendations:
https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2018/04/the-50-best-fantasy-novels-of-the-21st-century.html
Do you agree?
I can't say either way, I'd move some up, but I haven't read the entire list, and my personal choices are probably fine where they are. But ...
For me personally, Name of the Wind being on the list, let along the top, blows my mind. To each their own, but the book just reads as some snowflake character developed by Patrick Rothfuss who, in each new 'revelation' of the main character it just seems to be how much more special the main character can be made by the author. And by comparison for me, I was ready Farland's Runelords about the same time I picked up Name of the Wind. Runelords was way better for and those characters are arguably more snowflake'ish (ridiculous power levels), but they had more character each alone, there were more characters in the spotlight, and they included the necessity of supporting cast that Kvothe lacked other than the lone dark maverick with backstory to make him even more lone dark maverick. I guess for greats, Kvothe is up there with Drizzt and Wesley Crusher, but that's not my cup of tea.
ETA: I wouldn't put Runelords on any best of lists, but if I ever made a high-fantasy canon game, I'd consider going Runelords with characters having a small, limited number of Dedicates, focused on one region of Rofehavan. It sort of reads like the kind of book Farland might of hoped was picked up as an RPG or even a T/CCG with the way the runes work.