Girl Scout Cookies

silverfox

What are your favorites and why?

Roz

tagalongs because they are the best

GreenFlashlight

The caramel and coconut ones. The flavor combination is excellent and the texture of them is perfect.

Quinn

Thanks-A-Lot were the best and I'm mad they got rid of them.

I've always liked the peanut butter patties/tagalongs though. Just a good ratio of cookie to chocolate to peanut butter.

My kids do a taste test video every year so if anyone doesn't have a local cookie provider hit me up. They do online ordering and delivery these days and barring snow storms, shipping has been super fast even in COVID times.

Their favorite is the lemonades. My oldest says they have a 'sour lemon' taste but she likes the yellow chocolate on the bottom to balance it.

Three-Eyed Crow

@greenflashlight said in Girl Scout Cookies:

The caramel and coconut ones. The flavor combination is excellent and the texture of them is perfect.

I could inhale boxes of Samoas.

Also have a fondness for Thin Mints.

Too Old For This

Thin Mints. Lemon Ups. And Toffee-tastic.

My son is fond of the Tagalongs and S'mores.

mietze

Tagalongs and samoas! I've not tried any of the new ones tho.

Tinuviel

Us non-North Americans being very...

silverfox

@tinuviel I had a Canadian friend I'd RP with a lot a few years back. I learned she had never had thin mints before, so I sent her a box! She sent me maple cookies back. It was a good exchange.

Until a YEAR LATER she mentioned off hand, "Oh, I just found another sleeve of those cookies in my freezer!"

I WAS OFFENDED. (Because who doesn't eat all the thin mints within a day?!)

Ominous

@silverfox

Freezer thin mints are the best.

Except Tagalongs and Samoas, which are the actual best.

Ganymede

@ominous said in Girl Scout Cookies:

Freezer thin mints are the best.

Especially on ice cream.

Except Tagalongs and Samoas, which are the actual best.

fuck you dolphin

WildBaboons

@quinn said in Girl Scout Cookies:

Thanks-A-Lot were the best and I'm mad they got rid of them.

Those were the best. And also the best because almost everyone would read the name and then repeat in with a very sarcastic tone. Probably why they got rid of them.

Also I just looked. I still have 6 boxes of Girl Scout cookies from last year. whoops.

BetterNow

Samoas and Tagalongs for sure. Though the new Adventurefuls look DELICIOUS.

silverfox

@wildbaboons

YOU'RE A MONSTER

sahin

Lemonades. From the freezer.
Thin Mints. Same place.

magic

Macha

I thiiiiiiink it's Tagalongs? the peanut butter ones? And thin mints. And the samoas.

thankfully, I can get dupes for all these at Aldi, all year round.

Derp

Samoas 4 life. Thin mints too.

TNP

@macha said in Girl Scout Cookies:

I thiiiiiiink it's Tagalongs? the peanut butter ones? And thin mints. And the samoas.

thankfully, I can get dupes for all these at Aldi, all year round.

And cheaper too, I'm sure. I've never really understood the obsession

Derp

@tnp said in Girl Scout Cookies:

@macha said in Girl Scout Cookies:

I thiiiiiiink it's Tagalongs? the peanut butter ones? And thin mints. And the samoas.

thankfully, I can get dupes for all these at Aldi, all year round.

And cheaper too, I'm sure. I've never really understood the obsession

They're very much not the same though. Even though I get teh wal-mart samoas. DON'T JUDGE ME OK?

Macha

@derp I beg to differ. The peanut butter cookies from Aldi are AMAZING.