@Bobotron said:
A modern non-WoD supernatural game set anywhere but the East Coast, Las Vegas, or New Orleans.
EDIT: There was actually a small-town game a while back I got really excited about. It was set in the Southwest, had kind of a Night Vale vibe to it, and crashed and burned after like two months. I think it ran on FS3 (or whatever it's called)? People apped in some awesome shit, though.
Personally, I really like the "build your own monster" systems you can find in the Dresden Files RPG and Unisystem games like Buffy and Angel. I'd really enjoy a kind of bare-bones game without a lot of "franchise" elements, where people are allowed to app in pretty much whatever with those tools, with as much or as little society as makes sense for the creatures, all operating under a Veil Lite.