@sunny I honestly think we're on the same side on this one; I just didn't clarify actual fucked up OOC behavior
What I meant was is basically this:
Fucked up OOC behavior crosses a line. Harassment, attacking someone's RL (physically or through the web), Unwanted repeatable sexual advances, not taking no for an answer, blackmail, attacking one's reputation for personal gain, hacking a code system, siphoning contact information, stalking, abusive language such as threats or directed language intended to cause emotional harm...these are all very fucked up and clearly are in the realm of red card. If the targeted recipient of these chooses to never forgive or associate with that person again? Totally understandable. Totally reasonable. In fact, I think the people that do this stuff are a constant danger to anyone in any semi-anonymous hobby.
However, I think sometimes the offense is something not far from something that could be argued like a sports call: "He was IN!" "He was OUT!" This is stuff like: Differences in rules opinions, differences in what someone intended versus what someone meant to convey, various personal disagreements, headbutting personalities, accidental trigger-trippings, etc. I've seen and been party to miscommunications construed as something nefarious, resulting in people refusing to communicate over theories about why the miscommunications happened to begin with.
So... I think there's fucked up behavior and there's also this very gray realm of drama that goes on in this community where some people simply don't care, others try to work things out, some people agree to disagree and play nice, and then some others take things like disagreement and disappointment as an attack that cannot be forgiven.
Not everyone is fair, so the best you can do when it comes to forgiveness, try to be subjective, and (if the ball might have been on the line) try to suss it out.
My own personal approach that worked for me may not be the same as what works for others. I learned long ago that OOC can cause more problems than IC and to be very careful who I communicated with on an OOC level. For me? Reporting fucked up behavior, keeping pages and personal information to people I knew to trust, and stepping away from situations that bothered me on an OOC level worked for me. For me? It's online ether. Unless any of you were breaking the law or fucking with my RL there wasn't a damn thing happening in game that I couldn't walk away from to find enjoyment in Destiny 2 or hanging with friends.
But that is just me, not everyone, so I think the more people try to genuinely separate intentionally fucked up from disagreement, the better off your community will be.