@nyctophiliac said in Invisible Sun:
Oh I know this thread is way dead but I just found IS now and it looks really good I was wondering what your thoughts on it are after almost a year? Is it worth the $100 investment?
I think it is ONLY worth it if you have a dedicated group of players you can guarantee will invest and stick with it.
At some 250 for the base cube, 100 for the pdfs, 60 or so for the vislae kitsch, it's probably the most monetarily demanding RPG type hobby I've seen since Warhammer 40k.
I wouldn't buy it in the hope of finding players to play it with you. I would wait until you have a group of players who also want to invest and then pull the trigger.
More: Theres very little RPG-wise you can't do cheaper with a cheaper, hacked system, your own system, or finding a similar game. InvSun's biggest con point (as in pros vs cons) is that they placed a money gate on content that can be done cheaper in other systems.
Look at it this way. The "true" game is best with the game board (that per-scene changes the path of the suns and will alter +/- in play), the cool 6-fingered hand that holds the sun card for the whole session, and the hundreds of proprietary spell, equipment, etc cards.
The $100 pdfs contain all of the cards and can be printed, but are you willing to print them out? Make a board? Use some kind of card stand? How much extra will that cost to print those cards out?
IS worked hard to compartmentalize everything. The books have the names of spells, but the spell CARDS have the descriptions of what they do. To put both together you need the CARD and the BOOK. The $60 player kits have the book, but no cards. The $250 cube and $100 pdfs have the cards, but to randomly reward a player with a random spell you'd have to hand them a randomly shuffled card, which means needing some kind of printed card.
Very clever work was put into making sure pirating and sharing would lose them money, but the end result is that the game is very gatey and unwieldy if you havent shelled out the money they wanted you to.