So it's been a few weeks since I finally got myself signed up to the OR community site, and I've started some posts, and I've caused a little ruffle, and I've made some decent points, and here's my review:
Having a discussion on Optional Realities is like having a discussion with a young dog. There is a lot of silence coupled with what feels like tilting one's head and looking confused. I'm choosing to believe this as adorable.
The board has this 1-to-5 star rating system that is horribly outdated by modern social discussion standards. It's anonymous, as well, reducing it to counting the stains on a hotel mattress for all the good it does. It was explained to me that this system was to make sure that good posts were rewarded and "shit posters" are tagged. In practice, it's just as useful as WORA's old voting system.
The Optional Realities administration says they will discuss my suggestion to just go with a modern up-/down-vote system, or even just up-vote as positive reenforcement. Again, I get the sense that I might as well be throwing my suggestion into a slot over a suspiciously cylindrical container, one that is likely to be picked up and disposed of once per week.
It doesn't feel cozy, like some small communities can be. Its strongest personalities seem to be those we already know here: @Volund and @Griatch, as well as someone named "Unironicshitposter", which I find ironic since I don't see him shit-posting. Maybe I've just missed that phase.
I can't fault a new community for being new, but I can't find its soul nor its culture.