@Orange At least in my mind (I'm sure that's not universal though) consent-based games tend to be somewhat diceless, or at least keep mechanics around to see if specific actions succeed or fail or how powers work.
How are the WoD mechanics implemented there in that regard? For example you state that you "would so completely and severely lose to just about anyone who'd been there longer" but how can you lose if loss has to be consensual? Or what happens if you're in a PrP, you have all but two boxes of aggravated damage filled and an NPC rolls and scores 3 damage on you? I'm not sure if the limit of consent here is PC death (I haven't read the entire thread), what happens if you win the contested roll for Obfuscate vs Auspex so you start spying on someone but they say they don't want to be spied on?
Consent-based MU can be quite a lot of fun, I'm just not sure how the implementation works for the WoD.