I think @surreality is onto something awesome, and I'll be there.
When it comes to Lovecraftian/Aliens, the thing to remember is that in Lovecraft's writings, it was gigantic ziggurats rising out of the middle of the sea, and the doomed crew of the ship had no radio, no GPS, no tomahawk cruise missiles. Just ropes. Some pistols. Some ARRbecue sauce. Same thing goes for Cthulhu, Dagon, the Mountains of Madness. The technology level made being in the open sea with strange creatures a terrifying concept (or in Mountains case, in Antarctica). So, I think these ideas are an amazing addition to the setting, one that will have some definite life to it. Imagine:
- Pirate/Buccaneer crews chasing against time for mythical treasure?
- MONSTER ATTACKS
- I could go on and on, but there's no point. I've been chatting with surreality and she's had a keen eye on trying to put something together for the players, with no-nonsense policies, cool skill ideas, etc. I think she's onto something worth keeping an eye out for.
HELL, for the general Black Sails love both surreality and I share, the game will be in good hands. I could care less if there's a 7th Sea game in development. I prefer this idea.