@Arkandel
Still no. I'm not talking about people I despise because of the way they eat cereal, these are all people who left very bad tastes in my mouth due to my interaction with them in games. Some of them have cheated, some have behaved horribly towards their fellow players OOC, some are just asshats.
But, as long as they aren't cheaters, horrible jerks, or asshats in Arx? Great, fine.
My purpose staffing this game is not to sort people into naughty/nice based on my interactions with them outside the game, or punish them in some way for past behavior. It's to make sure the game is a decently civil, decently relaxed place to be where one can be confident that harrassers, cheaters, creeps and asshats will not be allowed to CONTINUE those behaviors in Arx, if they demonstrate them.
This whole second chance thing, honestly, comes down to the fact that I think lots of rp games have policies about OOC behavior that just aren't conducive to maintaining the atmosphere they want. People get shitty when placed in shitty situations. Taking, for example, Firan: Firan was not a horrible, completely terrible game full of non stop chicanery the way people make it out to be. It was not the devil. It wasn't even as traumatic an experience as the time I got a big box from Target that held a single pack of gum I never ordered.
But Firan's policies encouraged rule-skirting, players policing and witch hunting other players, and the suffocation and stifling of plot access, and those things made for some pretty unpleasant experiences for individual players.