@egg said in Diversity Representation in MU*ing:
Play a POC, it wouldn't kill you.
The character I've roleplayed the most in my life (Rinel Tern, theologian, literal Godbotherer, and generally cantankerous individual--come get into a fight with her on Arx today) is brown, and when I'm playing MMOs I tend to make my characters POCs.
Here's the thing, though. Those are fantasy worlds. It doesn't matter if my Jane Shepard is black, because by the time of Mass Effect it's species that matters, not race. It doesn't matter if Rinel looks like someone from India (except that maybe she'll not sunburn as easily?), because Arx is actually color blind.
But Marion, my second-gen Chinese immigrant character on Gray Harbor? I like Marion a lot, but playing them is hard. I have functionally no idea what it is like to grow up Chinese on the West Coast. I read a story as a kid about a girl who was embarrassed that she liked to eat fish eyes. I went to high school with a lot of first, second, and third gen immigrants (this is probably the most helpful thing). I try to read up on general cultural trends. But in terms of that lived experience?
I am not exaggerating when I say that it is easier to get into the head of Rinel Tern, a woman who literally punches demons, magically sees the movement of the wind in the sky, and yells at 800-year-old avatars of death and destruction for being rude than it is to play Marion. I don't mean this to say "oh wow people of color are totally alien and not understandable!" I mean it to say that if I fuck up on Rinel (and boy have I fucked up), I'm just someone who doesn't understand Oathlands culture. If I fuck up on Marion, I run the risk of being really offensive.
That doesn't mean I won't play POCs in real-world-adjacent settings. Obviously, I'll do that. But white folks should be aware that it deserves time and effort.