@insomniac7809 said in Separating Art From Artist:
@surreality said in Separating Art From Artist:
I do not support harassment, full stop. I believe what the Klan does is harassment. I do not believe that justifies promoting harassment of them in return. 'They do harm' does not justify harming people in the periphery of them, and it never will.
Taken to its conclusion, this sort of assertion prevents anyone from suffering any consequences for anything ever. No one is an island, after all; there is no such thing as a punishment that can avoid causing harm to the perpetrator's friends and loved ones.
...no? Am employer seeing the image and firing the employee (or even seeing the information) is not engaging in harassment. Friends abandoning the person are not engaging in harassment. And so on.
Taking the classic MSB dogpile, ramping it up by a factor of 100x or more the population, and sending off a fired up mob to do whatever they want with someone's personal information? That is harassment.
You know where this tactic has most commonly been used over the past twenty years or so, until quite recently, right? To publish the identities of people who worked at places that provided women's health, birth control, and abortion services. This has even extended to patients at times. To say 'that did not go well for the people whose identities were published' would be an understatement.
I'm going to -- gods help me -- share a personal story here. About 20 years ago now, I thought I had an ectopic pregnancy. I had to get a blood test to determine if this was the case before moving on to further testing, because that was the cheapest option when you didn't have insurance. The totally secular lab I went to for this had an employee who noticed that she was doing a pregnancy test from the forms she was sent, and went on and on about how thrilled I must be to have a baby on the way. I told her that wasn't the case, and they were concerned I had an ectopic pregnancy, so if I was pregnant, this story was unlikely to have any sort of happy ending. This medical professional chose to lecture me that I should still keep the pregnancy if that was the case, despite the fact that nobody survives if they do that.
And that would be bad enough, if things like 'murderer' didn't start getting scrawled on my car window in lipstick. If flyers weren't tacked to my door for over a year after that. If calls didn't come in from a number of pro-life activists and 'crisis counseling centers' for several months. It was very clear my name, address, and telephone number had been shared with these groups and there was very little doubt about who was responsible.
Spoiler alert: a cyst had burst, I was never pregnant. That didn't matter. The circumstances had I been pregnant didn't matter. (This wouldn't even be acceptable if I had been normally pregnant and had an abortion, either, obviously.)
This is where this shit goes. Stop pretending it's harmless make-believe 'just on the internet'. That is absolutely harassment, and people have only gotten a lot more ugly about it with the rise of social media and with a much larger population on the internet since that time.
@Kestrel I think adult children are a different animal than young dependents. Big names with money are also pretty different from a blue collar family that's feeling alienated and shoved out of society and responds the wrong way (with hate). Someone else mentioned offering support and showing that the people they're hating are not different from them in the gross ways the dogma they're embracing says, and that's a much healthier approach in those cases than harassment campaigns.