@Mr-Johnson said in Spitballing for a supers Mush:
Honestly another one of those things I've always wanted to do is Earth-2 where it's set at the late phase of the golden age. So 1960's or so, but you've got the Earth-2 continuity and characters and that feel, but over and over I get told the same thing.
We don't want historical settings we didn't LIVE in historical settings we don't want to learn. And that really breaks my heart.
[...]
Nothing else 'sells' DC only games even with an active Dev team don't sell. Marvel only doesn't sell. The market has shown over and over that people don't REALLY want anything new.
Honestly man? At this point in time, with the current events IRL especially but also the general decline of interest in the hobby over the last...decade, you might not ever get this magical self-sustaining number you want no matter what you do. That's just a risk you face in putting effort into opening a game.
In that case, I would suggest you stop focusing so hard on what other people want from a game and just make the game YOU would want to play in. Your passion for it will shine through, and other people who like the vibe will come play, and you'll wind up having a much better time and a lot more fun than if you were forcing yourself to just slog through some generic blah that has already existed a bajillion times and draws the same nasty, boring players playing the same characters.
Will it last? Maybe not? But again, there's just no guarantee it would anyway.
Just my two cents.