@faraday said in Wish Fulfillment RP:
It's also a bit illogical - like if you're in a room with Olympic athletes and Oscar-winning actors and somehow "nobody's special" just because everyone there is outstanding.
It's not that nobody is special but the baseline average has now been raised considerably. If you're at an Oscar party and someone asks "Who's the best actor here?" you're going to get a lot of different answers. It's more difficult for a single person to stand out in that room because they all have high "acting skills".
If, however, in that same room you have Mike Tyson and the question is "Who is the best fighter in the room?" the answer becomes much more obvious.
Edited to add that while I might argue the above point, I'm not oblivious to the real reason why other players don't acknowledge something special about other player's characters; because it might in some way suggest that their character is somehow less special. Player arrogance is the real problem, of that I am aware.