@lithium said in Good TV:
I still dislike the change to klingons, but if you can get past that, Discovery was actually very well done imho. Enjoyed it.
I did -- out of context -- love all the concept design for them. Like, that was a pretty, pretty, beautifully conceived everything.
But it bothered me in the sense that... that was a lot of frou frou, which is often a contradiction for a highly martial society. There are exceptions, but I don't know enough about the original concept/world-building for the Klingons originally (or in their current incarnation) to know if it fits.
As in, it's the kind of stylistic choice that seems to pick them up out of the 'barbarians with an honor code' sort of feel, which is how the old version used to seem to me, to something more akin to samurai composing battle poetry in their heads and so on. Which is neat, sure, but it is a big change and more importantly, it's not necessarily one I'm convinced they intended.
Why: a lot of it is artsy for artsy ornamentation sake (potentially with some symbolic/religious/spiritual overtones). Yeah, it's a big break from the more industrialist approach we've seen before, which is fine, and I wasn't expecting that, but what we're seeing breaks my brain in some respect because it would mean the armies of craftsmen in the Klingon empire would have to outnumber the soldiers by a factor of like, ten to one at least without raising a lot of other questions that get my brain stuck in boggle-loops on the regular.
I love the ever living hell out of the visual design. Love love love. OMFG love love love. Could not love more. Love like I loved the design for the original Stargate when it first hit theaters back in the 90s kinds of love.
Just, from what I've seen of it all so far? What I know of the 'old version' (and my interpretations of it), the design (no matter how gorgeous I think it is), and the few eps I've seen so far... it doesn't all fit together in my head in a cohesive way, even with the 'maybe they're going for a more... ' approach thing in mind.
Maybe that just a 'yet' and I need to watch more of it? But while I don't hate it, it is a bit of a ????? that I've been having trouble getting my brain around properly and it's getting in the way of enjoying it (while being a reason to enjoy it because omfg shiny as fuck -- gahhhhhhh all the mindscramble!).