@arkandel said in Potential Buffy Game:
That's the thing though. What makes Buffy Buffy is a very specific blend of themes without which it is just a generic urban fantasy game.
Like @Coin said - what makes a show special is different to different people. The characters, the snappy writing, the campiness, the teenage coming-of-age drama, the smallish-town setting, the idea of the Slayers, the Scooby Gang stuff... these things and more are components of Buffy, but everyone values some of them more than others.
Battlestar Galactica, for instance, obviously puts a great deal of emphasis on the Top Gun fighter pilot aspect. But you could do a completely non-military BSG game and it would still, IMHO, be "A BSG Game". It may not be what you or anyone else sees as "what defines BSG to me", but that doesn't make it illegitimate or anything.