@Ganymede said in Separating Art From Artist:
@bored
It was a question of whether it was acceptable behavior.
I mean, I understand from the discussion that we are talking about shaming. Shaming people for their bad behavior. And if that means affecting their life so be it.
The line I see is whether the shaming leads to physical consequences. It is clearly wrong if someone is assaulted or killed as a result of exposing them.
But losing one’s job? Some people think that the truth hurts. But it also hurts children who depend on that job. Does the morality depend on what a person is being shamed for?
I guess that’s why I err on the side of not shaming.
I don't know if any of you have read / listened to Jon Ronson's work, "So you've been publicly shamed" - it discusses these issues.
For me, I have marched in protests around Brexit and the NHS - I work in the public sector and didn't cover my face. Honestly? I believe in those things, and if I were identified, I would stand by them. BUT I am also covered by solid employment laws and good unions and so there isn't a fear of my income being affected. So it wasn't a major risk for me - my sector is notoriously left-leaning, anti-Brexit, pro-NHS.
I love a video of a nazi being punched as much as the next left-wing person. But I feel that is the part of us - all of us - who would watch gladiators. The same reason some people read threads on here with popcorn.